Book reviews


Hmm. When one is given a book by a dearly loved aunt, one reads the book, then wonders whether or not to be honest when reviewing the book. If one doesn’t enjoy the book and says so, will the dearly loved aunt’s feelings be hurt? One wouldn’t want that to happen, but one is also obliged to be honest when writing book reviews.

The Uncommon Reader by Alan Bennett is the first book I have read by this author, who has written a number of enormously successful plays, screenplays, novels and autobiographies, including The Lady in the Van.

The main character in The Uncommon Reader is the Queen. While walking the corgis in the palace grounds, she comes across a mobile library and borrows a book.

While the first book she borrows is not to her taste, the Queen borrows another and eventually, becomes a book worm. Her official duties start to suffer, but her opinions develop. Eventually, palace staff, politicians and equerries try to dissuade the Queen from further reading.

While The Uncommon Reader is clever, it wasn’t for me. I hadn’t read any of the books the Queen read, so couldn’t find a connection there, and the Queen was unfortunately put off reading Jane Austen by all of the people who told her how much she would enjoy her works, losing the one chance I had of being won over.

There were plenty of characters who are actual English politicians and society people in the story but as an Australian these were lost on me. Probably someone who knew of these people might have found humour where I didn’t.

I expect I’ll see the movie of The Lady in the Van sometime, but will probably not read another book by this author. This may be stupid of me, but life is short…

The last book I gave my aunt was about 15 years ago, Welcome to Temptation by Jennifer Crusie. Welcome to Temptation is a cheerful and smutty  romance which my aunt very kindly described as “great fun.” I doubt that Welcome to Temptation would make the Queen’s reading list though.




Comments on: "The Uncommon Reader by Alan Bennett" (13)

  1. RedHeadedBookLover said:

    Hi there! I just wanted to say that I really enjoyed this blog post of yours… Not just this one but all of them! They are all honestly really great and amazing.
    I should mention that because of how much I loved this post of yours I had to check out your blog and I couldn’t help but follow you because your blog is literally amazing and I truly am so happy that I have come across it because I really love it and I truly can’t wait to read more from you! So keep it up (:
    P.s. This comment is towards all of your blog posts because they are all equally amazing and incredible, keep up the great work (:

  2. I’ve read The Lady in the Van and also The Clothes They Stood Up In, and didn’t get either one. The synopsis for The Uncommon Reader does sound interesting however from your review it sounds I may not get this one either.

  3. I did like this a bit better than you, because the references were familiar to me. But I don’t think it’s Alan Bennett at anything like his best. In fact, I prefer his autobiographical books to his fiction, and some of his plays for TV were brilliant. But I think he’s a totally English writer – not sure any of his stuff would travel well…

  4. I was a bit anxious admitting that I didn’t get this story, so you’ve eased my mind enormously by commenting, thank you so much! Maybe I’ll just watch The Lady in the Van movie.

  5. Oh, wow, thank you. It’s great to come across so many other book lovers on WordPress.

  6. I knew it! This story reminded me a little of an ‘in’ group, with their own stories and jokes and history and unless you’re part of the group, you’ll never fit in. If the names were changed to Australian football players with football in-jokes, I would love it.

  7. I’ve just watched The Lady in the Van, followed by a rather charming documentary following Bennett across a year of his life (2015). And I found him the most charming companion. I’m keen to read some of his autobiographical stuff but the blurb on this book left me cold. I’d already decided – shock horror – not to add this one to the list. And your thoughts affirm that decision 🙂

  8. Don’t let me put you off! I’m Australian, so I probably missed all sorts of references that an English reader would enjoy. I’m looking forward to watching The Lady in the Van though.

  9. The film is delightful – very English certainly, but perfectly accessible I think. Anything featuring Maggie Smith tends to get my vote!

  10. Agreed, she is wonderful. I’ve just discovered Downton Abbey and am particularly loving her snarky put-downs 🙂

  11. Oh gosh – Downtown is practically an institution here; I loved it and shall rewatch the whole thing happily in time. Maggie Smith and her put-downs are wonderful. Enjoy!

  12. Her Lady in the Van character and the Dowager Countess have a number of characteristics in common!

  13. All the more reason to watch The Lady in the Van sooner rather than later, then 🙂

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: