Book reviews


Commonwealth by Ann Patchett is a good book, however I loved Bel Canto by this author so much that I can’t quite forgive Commonwealth for not being as good. My problem, not the book’s. I should have waited another year before reading it.

Commonwealth tells the story of the children of a blended family with six children over a fifty year period. The story starts at the christening of the youngest girl, Franny, when her mother is kissed by an uninvited guest who brought a bottle of gin to the party. This was in the 1960s, so having the words ‘christening’ and ‘gin’ in the same sentence wasn’t as odd as it would be now.

The two adults, Beverly and Bert fell in love and dissolved their families to start a new one with her two children, and his four. The story then follows the children as they grow up together, running wild all summer. Six children are too many for Beverly to manage and Bert takes no responsibility for them at all and tragically, the lack of supervision leads to the death of the eldest boy, Cal.

The children make it clear that their parents fell in love with the idea of escaping their real lives (and for Bert particularly, the responsibility of his children) as much as they fell in love with each other. Their marriage didn’t last either, as Bert eventually played around on Beverly too. They divorced and both went on to third marriages.

As interesting as I found the adult’s story, though, the story of Commonwealth belongs to the children. Beverly’s daughters are Caroline, the aggressive, bossy older sister who leads the pack, and Franny, who floats along, letting life take her where it will. As a twenty-something, Franny falls into a relationship with a much older celebrated author, who hears the story of her childhood and uses it to write a successful novel. Franny tells most of the story, although occasionally the point of view switches to another character. The story isn’t told chronologically, probably because if it had been there would have been nothing for the characters left to discover about themselves later on.

Bert’s children are Cal, who died as a teenager, Holly, who abandons life in the USA to spend her days meditating in Switzerland, Jeanette, who everyone thought was mentally deficient as a child but who turned out to be the most well-adjusted of them all and Albie, the youngest boy whose story was in some ways the saddest of all. Albie was such a painful child that no one could bear to be around him.

Two characters I would like to know more about were Father Joe Mike and Beverly’s sister Bonnie, but I suspect I never will. They go together like gin at a christening.

Ann Patchett’s writing has a feel of Jane Austen to me, in that she (or rather her narrator), is amused by her characters and their lives. I like this style enormously. I liked Commonwealth enormously too, but am going to wait longer before reading another book by this author so that I can enjoy it without comparison to Commonwealth or Bel Canto.





Comments on: "Commonwealth by Ann Patchett" (4)

  1. Don’t people get drunk at christenings any more then? Good heavens! What do they do then? 😉

    I’ve only read one book of Patchett’s State of Wonder, which I enjoyed with a few reservations around credibility – but then you know me and credibility! At that time, everyone recommended Bel Canto to me and I will get around to it… one day…

  2. No idea, I haven’t been to a Christening in years! Do people still have them? (Babies, that is!)
    I think I’m a more gullible reader than you are. Maybe you’ve read so much crime that you’ve developed a radar for stretching a possibility too far. State of Wonder is on my list, will read it before checking out your review in case I am influenced by your credibility issues 😉

  3. I enjoyed Bel Canto too but I never raved over it as many did and have. I don’t remember what made it a good read which means it didn’t speak to my heart or mind – it was just a nicely written read. However, I have read her non-fiction work – was it Truth and beauty (?) which I recollect was interesting. I’d be happy to read Commonwealth given all the positive things I’ve heard.

  4. I do like her non-fiction work, she has strong opinions and expresses them well. Her non-fiction reminded me a little of Helen Garner’s Everywhere I Look, they have the same fearlessness in saying it as they see it.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: