Book reviews


I’m enjoying working my way through Margaret Atwood’s fiction, most recently, Moral Disorder and other stories, a collection of short stories from 2006.

The collection tells stories from different periods of the main character’s life. She is un-named until about three-quarters of the way through the book, when ‘Nell’ appears. I have assumed that the earlier stories are also about Nell, although this is unconfirmed.

The first story, The Bad News, introduces the main character and her partner, Tig, in their old age. They have developed patterns of behaviour throughout their many years together, one of which is that Tig, who gets up first in the morning and watches the news, is not to tell Nell any bad news until after she has eaten her breakfast.

The Art of Cooking and Serving is a story of Nell as a little girl willingly working in the family home and helping out her mother with her little sister until one day as a teenager she rebels, telling her mother, “She’s not my baby. I didn’t have her. You did.”

The stories feel so true that they could be autobiographical. The Headless Horseman tells of Nell making a costume for Halloween which alternately fascinates and terrifies her much younger sister and My Last Duchess of a class in school where Robert Browning’s poem is being studied. This story was one of my favourites. I didn’t know the poem, so enjoyed looking it up, but I also loved that Nell was learning life lessons, recognising the end of her latest romantic relationship and even more importantly, learning to recognise and value her teachers and the hidden values they were trying to impart to Nell and her fellow students.

The Other Place shows Nell as a young woman, moving often, changing jobs and boyfriends, and not seeing her parents, who disapprove of her lifestyle. Monopoly tells of the early days of Nell’s relationship with Tig, a separated father of two and Nell’s own relationship with Tig’s ex-wife. The title story, Moral Disorder, was another of my favourites and superficially tells of Nell and Tig learning to farm and feeling guilty that chickens they have grown (and named) taste delicious when roasted. This story reminded me of growing up on a farm, as whenever we had a lamb in the backyard Dad called the lamb Chop-Chop so there would be no illusions about why the lamb was in our yard.

White Horse has Nell as an adult, again caring for her younger sister. The Entities shows Nell and Tig moving house, then The Labrador Fiasco and The Boys at the Lab has Nell reunited with and caring for her parents in their old age.

The more I read by Margaret Atwood, the more I appreciate her stories and her wonderfully clear writing.

Comments on: "Moral Disorder and other stories by Margaret Atwood" (10)

  1. I really must read more Atwood! My Last Duchess is a great poem, isn’t it? So spine-tingling! It’s one of the very few poems I learned at school that I can still quotes big chunks of. I’m so glad I’m a puny city-dweller – I don’t think I could eat an animal I’d known personally… 😉

  2. Thanks for this Rose. I try to keep an eye on Atwood, though it’s a long time since I’ve read her. I read several before blogging, and I have a couple on my TBR since. But, I don’t even recollect hearing about this one. I do like connected short stories. And you are right, she’s a wonderful writer. I went to an author event/conversation featuring her once – probably late 90s or perhaps early 2000s. She was impressive – but scary too in her absolute, crisp, sharp intelligence. She doesn’t ket people get away with anything.

  3. My Last Duchess is a great poem and the short story really did it justice. I’ve never studied poetry and really appreciated the character analysing the poem throughout the story.
    I went to lunch recently with a group and the host chose a fish from a tank for our meal which put several people off eating… all the more for the farm girl…

  4. I think she would make mince meat of anyone who tried to get away with anything she didn’t approve of! I expect the event was memorable.
    I’m really enjoying her stories. I think it’s her honesty that I like best.

  5. Haha, yes, she would. I was terrified and glad I wasn’t doing the interviewing!!

  6. I seem to be one of the few who struggles to appreciate Atwood. Why is that? I wish I knew! I feel that I ought to like her books, appreciate her writing etc but whenever I read her stuff I feel unsettled and it doesn’t feel like a positive experience. I’m answering my own question it seems: maybe I just struggle with disquiet! Anyway, this collection sounds promising. Perhaps it might be a way in for me 🙂

  7. I hadn’t come across this one, and I’ve read lots of Atwood – I wish she would take a break from writing and let me catch up! Sounds very good.

  8. I think you did answer your own question, Sandra. Atwood’s stories are uncomfortable and leave me feeling uneasy. I definitely wouldn’t read one when I need a comfort read!

  9. Sorry, I hit ‘send’ too quickly. You might enjoy these short stories better than a full length novel, they are less confrontational than some of her novels.

  10. Hi Jane, yes, she certainly is prolific. I feel comforted knowing I’ve got loads of her books still to read 🙂

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: