Book reviews

Too Much Lip by Melissa Lucashenko was the winner of the Miles Franklin Literary Award for 2019 and as such, was the obvious choice for me to begin fulfilling my New Year’s resolution of buying a book by an Australian author each month.

Not only was Too Much Lip the obvious choice, but it turned out to be a thought-provoking, unsettling and worrying look at an Australia that I know exists, but ignore. What am I ignoring? The contemporary version of Australia that many (not all) Aboriginal Australians live in. Why do I ignore this Australia? For my own peace of mind. I’m a privileged white Australian with everything I want and more. I’m automatically trusted and respected, I have choices. I have my family around me, work I enjoy and financial freedom. I have the support of the law. I was encouraged to continue my education. I’ve never been subjected to racism of any kind. I’m very grateful to be who I am, which came about just from being born. Most of the Aboriginal characters in this book don’t have and are unlikely to get what I have. Those that do are what the other characters derogatorily call ‘coconuts,’ Aboriginal people who live their life according to ‘white’ values. The question now is, can I keep ignoring these differences in real life?

Too Much Lip is set in a fictional town in Woop-Woop called Durrongo, in Bundjalung country in northern NSW. The name Durrongo amused me because it reminded me of ‘drongo,’ an Australian slang word for an idiot. I’d love to know if the author planned this. One of the characters refers to the town as the “Place of Centrelink fraud”.

The main character is Kerry Salter, who roared back to her family home on a stolen Harley Davidson motorbike with a backpack full of cash from a robbery her girlfriend had just been sent to prison for. Kerry’s Pop, who was both respected and feared throughout the Salter family and greater community, was dying and Kerry only planned on staying around long enough to say goodbye.

Kerry’s Pop grew up on a mission and did not know where his country was. As an Aboriginal, this meant that a vital part of his self was missing. As a successful boxer he earned some protection from the trouble that most Aboriginal people experienced from white Australians and later in life was able to provide his family with a home of their own and some security. Kerry’s mother, Pretty Mary, a former alcoholic, was nursing him as he lay dying.

Also living in the family home was Kerry’s brother Ken, a big, angry, former football star who had recently been released from prison. Kenny’s violent temper kept everyone around him on tenterhooks as he bullied his way through life. Kerry was horrified to realise that Kenny’s teenage son Donny was very often the brunt of his irrational rages and was suffering from anorexic.

Kerry usually bolted when the going got tough, but when her backpack full of stolen cash was stolen from her by a local politician, Jim Buckley, she stayed on in Durrongo, planning to steal it back. When she learned that Buckley was selling the land on the local river to a consortium who planned to build a jail, Kerry and the rest of the extended Salter family decided to fight the development as a land rights issue. The river and Granny Ava’s Island was more meaningful to them than I could have imagined, as the location of where Kerry’s pregnant great-grandmother Ava had been shot swimming across the river to escape white men. The river was also the home of the totem animal of the men of the family, a shark.

Kerry’s stay in town became more complicated when she met Steve, who she remembered as a dorky schoolboy but who was now a very attractive man. The only thing wrong with him is that he was white. And a man.

Kerry’s trait of ‘too much lip’ referred to her inability to keep quiet rather than voice her opinion, particularly when negotiating her way around Kenny.

While it took me a long time to stop feeling as if I were being assaulted by the constant, often vicious swearing, I accept that this also felt true to how the characters should speak. The language in this book was full of a slang that I recognised but don’t use, but also included words I don’t know, Aboriginal words such as ‘jahjams’ for children, ‘womba’ for crazy and ‘gunjies’ for police.

I was constantly shocked by the violence which the family took for granted, the crime, the poverty, the drinking, the gambling and the double standards, even those that they used themselves (for example, Kerry was furious when her cash was stolen from her, but ignored the fact that it had been stolen by her girlfriend in the first place). I was also irritated by the Salter family’s attitude towards Centrelink and government benefits, because as a worker, that’s my hard-earned tax the characters were treating as a right rather than a privilege, and their disregard for the law. Despite these moral quibbles, I was on Kerry’s side all the way through, regardless of the terrible choices she often made, as her and her family’s secrets were exposed. It was easy to recognise that their often shocking behaviours were just the symptoms of their family’s problems.

The family’s and local history continued to complicate the present for Kerry and her family. Aboriginal families were split up as children who were considered ‘white enough’ were stolen from their families. The children in the Salter family weren’t always safe from their own family members. Buckley’s grandfather had been a police officer who treated the Salter family and other Aboriginals in the area with terrible violence. The local policeman’s grandfather, who had settled the area and became a cattle baron, was even more violent than the politician’s grandfather, and had fathered a great many of the Aboriginal children in the area. Many wrong deeds continued to impact the people in this book for generations after each event.

Despite the questions racing around in my head, I found Too Much Lip to be a very funny book. There are moments of hope and joy and some inspirational characters, including Kerry’s Uncle Richard who showed Kenny a better way to live, by promoting traditional Aboriginal values instead of expressing himself violently. Kerry’s other brother, Black Superman, is another wonderful man who fosters emotionally and physically-damaged children. I loved reading about the character’s connections with birds and animals and of course, with the land which been built on over many generations of family stories. I also loved the glimpse of mystic connections with all of these elements which I believed in completely.

This has been a very difficult review to write. I’m not just commenting on a story, but on who Australians are. Not only that, but I’m publishing this on the Australia Day public holiday, which Kerry would hate (Invasion Day). Australia Day means something different to all of us, but we are all Australian and this year I’ll be thinking of what it means to be an Australian, thanks to this book.

Too Much Lip has left me with a lot of questions about what we have to do next, as a nation and as individuals, to be the best that we can. I feel as I’ve made a beginning by listening.

Too Much Lip came to my attention after Whispering Gums reviewed the book last year. You can read Sue’s review here:

I’ll be tracking my progress of my New Year’s Resolution to buy a book by an Australian author each month on my ‘Buying Australian’ page.

Comments on: "Too Much Lip by Melissa Lucashenko" (13)

  1. Great review! It’s good that finally we’re hearing the stories of the Aboriginals and other indigenous people around the world in their own voices though it certainly doesn’t make for comfortable reading. I remember many years ago going to see a film called Once Were Warriors, about Maoris in NZ, with a Kiwi friend of mine, and while I found it pretty grim viewing she was shocked to the core. Hope you find many more great reads in your Australian quest!

  2. So glad you chose this as you first book to read in your Buying Australian plan, Rose. It’s such a wonderful book exactly because it’s not simplistic, because it confronts us to think about the things you’ve identified. I love how you’ve written about it.

    Your comment about their attitude to Centrelink and your feelings about that, reminded me of something Ruth Park said in her memoir Drums Go Bang and people living in poverty, people living without all those things you identified that people like you and I have. She wrote about the poor of Surry Hills:

    “she began to understand how the incredible congestion of their lives, the rabbit-warren houses, the inescapable dirt of an area which is built around the big factory chimneys all contributed to their innately lawless, conventionless attitude towards life. She began to understand that in such a place dirt ceases to become important, morals are often impracticable, and privacy is an impossibility.”

    I think this is something we all need to understand – the way people behave may no be right, but the way they’ve been treated isn’t right either is it. Too much lip is so clever in being real about the people while at the same time making us see why things are as they are. It was a brave book for her to write.

  3. Too Much Lip was extremely uncomfortable reading! I’ve nevertheless seen Once We Were Warriors, too violent for me, but I’ve read something else by the book’s author, Alan Duff which was very good. I’ve been looking for other books by him ever since but haven’t come across any.

  4. Too Much Lip is an extraordinary book which I appreciated very much. I agree that the characters did what they had to in order to get on. Ruth Park’s example is apt.
    You’re right about it being a brave book for the author to write. It exposes so many uncomfortable, hurtful, difficult issues. Thank goodness they were balanced with joy and fun and love, as well as the character’s connections with the land and their families and communities.
    I always think the best authors are those who are fearless about their writing. Melissa Lucashenko certainly demonstrated that quality in this book. I don’t think I could have started my Buying Australian plan with a better book.

  5. Gosh, this has got me thinking. It sounds very much like a book I would like to read but I’m wondering if it is ‘too Australian’ for me to be able to appreciate it. One day(!) I will post my thoughts on The Tree of Man, which brought home to me that sometimes we need to be sufficiently close to a country’s psyche to fully appreciate a book which exposes that psyche. Reading more Australian lit is one of the many things I’d like to tackle this year so your plan to read a book a month will be really helpful in guiding the way!

  6. It’s so difficult going outside our comfort zones isn’t it, but you’ve done it and this was a really interesting review, I wonder how it will compare and fit in with your upcoming Australian reads?

  7. Oh, this book is full on! The character’s voices are so rough, so confronting, so angry and very, very Australian, even though theirs isn’t always my Australia. There are so many versions of Australia though, that I imagine every Australian reader would have a different reaction. I’d love to read an international reader’s opinion of this book.
    Yes, I still feel guilty when I think of you suffering through my beloved The Tree of Man! Too Much Lip would be a very different experience but I’m hesitant to recommend this one to you. I’m planning to read some less-known or emerging Australian writers through the year, so hopefully some will appeal to you. Otherwise, Tim Winton is very highly regarded, as is Kate Grenville, Richard Flanagan and Sophie Laguna.

  8. My plan is to read emerging and less-known writers, which probably means more uncomfortable reading than I am used to from Australian writers. Too Much Lip was an excellent start to my year’s reading (and buying).

  9. Oh dear, Rose, please don’t think I ‘suffered’ through it! I didn’t have the same response as you did, it’s true, but I am glad that I read it and I learned a lot from it. Tim Winton is on my (very short) list. I suspect that list will grow as this year goes on!

  10. Great review! This sounds like a fascinating, if hard, story. In Canada we have a somewhat similar history with our Indigenous peoples. Fiction can be such a powerful way to share these stories and shed light on the truth.

  11. Oh, thank goodness. As for your list, I’ll do my best 🙂

  12. Thank you! Too Much Lip really is a remarkable book.
    I don’t know much about Canadian history but it seems as if colonisation meant suffering for the Indigenous people, regardless of where in the world it occurred.

  13. Unfortunately, I think that’s very true.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: