Book reviews

I chose to read My Name is Red by Turkish author Orhan Pamuk for my Classics Club challenge as I had not read any novels from this part of the world previously.

I was surprised to find that the story is a murder mystery and found it to be the most unusually-told murder mystery I’ve ever read. For example, the first chapter was told by the corpse, who was lying dead in the bottom of a well.

Each chapter was told by someone or something associated with the story. The narrators included students, associates and family members of the murdered man, while others were narrated by a picture of a horse, a gold coin, the colour red and by death itself. One of the narrators is the actual murderer, although their identity is not revealed until the end of the story.

The story is set in 1591 in Istanbul. The murdered man, Elegant Effendi was a master miniaturist who had been creating a mysterious illustrated book with the assistance of other miniaturists from his studio prior to his death.

Elegant Effendi beautiful daughter, Shekure was thinking of remarrying as her soldier husband had been missing for several years. Shekure’s romance with Black, an administrator who had been in love with her since their childhood also ran through the story.

Black, who was also under suspicion of Elegant Effendi’s murder along with Master Osman, another master miniaturist, sought to find the murderer from clues in the pages of the Sultan’s books. I was shocked to learn that the Sultan’s collection of beautifully illustrated and gilded books were stored in a haphazard stash and seemingly not valued at all by the Sultan except as possessions.

The introduction of the Frankish style of art, which threatened the highly-stylised traditional art style which the miniaturists made their living from was another theme that ran through the story.

I loved the references to the miniaturist’s art and their opinions and feelings about the Frankish art. The various miniaturist’s opinions also related to their interpretation of whether or not the subjects and style of Frankish art was in keeping with their religious views, which did not allow them to create art, only to copy what already existed.

The story also references real books and stories of the time. My Name is Red would make a delightful coffee-table sized book, with pictures. The tragic story of a pair of lovers named Husrev and Shirin was constantly referenced and a very quick search on the internet brought up beautiful gilded illustrations of the pair.

I was unpleasantly surprised by the great many vulgar references in this story. Most of the male characters openly had physical relationships with very young boys and the chapter told from the point of view of a coin was an eye-opener, as I’ve certainly never thought of hiding money in the places that particular coin had been. There are also references to incest, bestiality and other practices which may have been considered normal and right at the time the story is set, but I found these parts of the book to be distasteful and would say and probably spoiled the story for me.

I also found the book to be hard work, in that I needed to concentrate hard in order to make sense of the weighty descriptions. It helped that the chapters are fairly short and the narrators changed with each chapter.

My Name is Red was book twenty one in my Classics Club challenge to read 50 classics before my challenge end date of August 26, 2023.

Comments on: "My Name is Red by Orhan Pamuk" (15)

  1. Quite some time ago I was given a two books by Pamuk: this one and Snow. In one of those bizarre coincidences, I’ve read your review today and I have another I’m about to read on ‘Snow’. So odd! The books stand out in my mind because I never read them – I gave them away. I’d never heard of this author and I felt the books were just not right for me. Only much later did I learn more about who Pamuk is and I’ve always felt annoyed at myself for having passed on these books without giving them a try. Having read your thoughts, Rose, perhaps my first instincts were right. I’m not sure I would enjoy hearing more about that coin! πŸ˜–

  2. I was feeling quite confident of giving this a go until I read your last paragraph! I’ve had this on the shelf for years and keep looking at it and wondering and then deciding no. I think it might have moved up to a maybe from your very clear review, thank you!

  3. Interesting review! I haven’t read any by this author. Although the narrative point of view sounds intriguing I am put off by those references you mention… Also I’m not a fan of weighty descriptions. I did look at his book ‘Snow’ (which is on my library e-book catalogue) but I could tell the density of the style would be hard work.

  4. Hmm, you’d nearly sold this one to me until you mentioned the vulgarity and bestiality, etc. Think I’ll pass…

  5. That is a coincidence!
    Snow is supposed to be very good, however I don’t see myself reading anything more by this author either.
    Years ago when I worked on a shop counter I had an elderly customer put his coins into his mouth before giving them too me. Even before reading the chapter told by the gold coin I thought his habit was disgusting. I can remember marching out the back to wash my hands every time I served him.

  6. I’ll certainly look forward to your review if this book ever turns from a maybe to a yes for you πŸ™‚
    I believe Snow is very good, but I probably won’t read anything more by this author. My Name is Red was very good but I’m probably not literary enough to have fully appreciated it.

  7. The different points of view were fascinating, although sometimes it took me a while to figure out who the narrator was even though they were named in each chapter. The colour red, for example. I kept thinking the narrator was a person named Red.
    Several people have recommended Snow to me and have said they preferred it to My Name is Red, so perhaps it would be a better starting point if you are inclined to read this author.

  8. I didn’t get the feeling that any of these things were only in the story for shock value as the nastiness was taken for granted by the characters as part of their world. It left me feeling uncomfortable. though.

  9. I’ve ‘liked’ this comment but I don’t like it. You know what I mean I hope! πŸ€”

  10. I know exactly what you mean πŸ™‚
    Sometimes we need a button for ‘acknowledge’ rather than ‘like’. I’ll tell WordPress!

  11. πŸ‘πŸ˜†

  12. I will keep Snow in mind but I have been abandoning an awful lot of library e-books this year after reading a chapter or two so I’m choosing very carefully now!

  13. I wish I was better at abandoning books I don’t like…

  14. I am more ruthless at it, there are too many books and not enough time πŸ™‚

  15. True. I’m going to adopt that motto.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: