Book reviews

Field of Poppies is the first novel I’ve read by Australian author Carmel Bird. The author’s bio says she has written 11 novels and eight short story collections, been short-listed three times for the Miles Franklin Award and won the Patrick White Literary Award. I can’t think why I haven’t read anything by her before.

The story is narrated by Marsali Swift, who with her husband William moved to the fictional town of Muckleton in central Victoria from Melbourne in what is popularly known in Australia as a ‘tree-change’. In Muckleton, Marsali and William lived in a grand old house called Listowel and immersed themselves into the community, even though the locals know that anyone from the city are just blow-ins. To be a local people’s parents, grandparents and preferably their great-grandparents had to have lived in the area too.

First of all, Muckleton. If that place isn’t real, then it should be if only for the name alone. I kept saying Muckleton over and over again as I was reading, just because I like how the name sounds. I have a mental image of Muckleton and think it must be similar to the central Victorian town of Castlemaine, which has an enormously grand Post Office that was built on the promise of gold, gold and more gold being found in the district. Also, there is also a small town called Muckleford just a few kilometres from Castlemaine. Close enough?

Sigh. I’ve fallen down a rabbit hole. This isn’t surprising because Marsali’s narration was a succession of anecdotes which hopped from one to another. Some of Marsali’s stories were about Muckleton residents, places or events, while others were based on discussions of novels from Marsali’s book group who read Joan Lindsay’s Picnic at Hanging Rock and Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland after a local Muckleton woman named Alice Dooley disappeared. Marsali’s version of events were occasionally interrupted by William’s Wise Words, where he chimed in to add to the story with interesting and detailed facts.

A great many of the anecdotes were related to Claude Monet’s painting The Poppy Field, or a copy of the painting which was made by Marsali’s Aunt Clarissa, who was a talented copyist artist.

One night, when Marsali and William had driven to Melbourne to attend an opera (La Traviata) at the Arts Centre, Listowel was robbed. The thieves were two local men whose vehicle hit a kangaroo while they were leaving town with the loot. One of the men died in the accident but the other was charged with theft then went back to his Real Estate business, without any loss of business by the locals. Marsali and William’s antiques and collectables were returned to them along with the copy of The Poppy Field, but how they felt about Muckleton changed.

The disappearance of Alice didn’t help, but when a Chinese gold mine started up, bringing jobs and noise and dust to the town and to Listowel in particular, since the road to the mine went past their back door, Marsali and William upped stumps and moved back to a high-rise apartment in Melbourne (in the Eureka Tower, mind you. I’ve been up to the skydeck to look at the view over Melbourne and it is sensational. The Eureka Tower was named for Australia’s own Eureka Stockade, where gold miners took on the English authorities who were taxing them out of existence).

I loved the rambling, inter-connected story-telling style of Field of Poppies. I loved Muckleton and its community. I loved the idealism of the tree-changers. I loved the opinions of the book club’s members of the books they read. I loved the coincidences and the randomness of the anecdotes. I’ll definitely be reading more of Carmel Bird’s stories in future.

Comments on: "Field of Poppies by Carmel Bird" (17)

  1. Oh, I love that you “get” Carmel Bird and her wonderful style Rose. I have no idea why she isn’t better known and more read than she is. I love her discursive (used in its positive meaning) style.

    I suspect your musings on Muckleton’s origins are pretty spot on!

    • I loved her funny, musing style in this book. I felt as if I was having a conversation with a friend and listening to all the latest news about town.
      I have Home Truth in my bookcase, too so something to loom forward to 🙂

  2. This sounds quite unique. And a lot of fun! Glad you enjoyed it, Rose.

  3. Yes, that’s a good description. I loved her funny, musing style too – the way she goes off on tangents that are entertaining (but have art behind them all the same.)

  4. I am 100% with you regarding the name Muckleton – absolutely brilliant! 😁 It sounds like a wonderful book. Short stories don’t always work for me, but it helps a lot if they are interconnected.

  5. This does sound fun, I love your rabbit hole!

  6. I feel like this book might be a bit too rambling for me but I do enjoy a good glimpse into small town life. I live in one of those small towns where you’re not a local unless you were born here!

    • Small towns are the perfect setting for stories as well as real life. Being a newcomer in a small town can be difficult, though. Other times there are benefits to being an outsider!
      I’m sorry if I’ve put you off this book, the rambling nature suits the story very well.

  7. The way you describe the rambling anecdotal style reminds me a bit of Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead – it’s a life story, or rather the story of a family’s history, but with lots of little set-pieces inserted about events that have happened to them over the years. Sounds like you’ve found a new favourite!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: