Book reviews

The Visitors by Jane Harrison

The Visitors by Australian author Jane Harrison tells a story of the arrival of the First Fleet in Sydney Harbour from the point of view of the First Nations people, who watched the eleven sailing ships arrive on Gadigal land on January 26, 1788.

On the day, seven Aboriginal Elders from seven different clans gathered on a high cliff overlooking the harbour where the ships had anchored, which were larger than any bark canoe the watching Elders could ever have imagined. The seven men then spent their day trying to come to a unanimous decision about whether the unwanted visitors should be welcomed to country or made to leave.

Based on their experiences from an earlier visit by people in sailing ships, initially most of the Elders wanted to repel the unwanted arrivals but as the day went on, even though the visitors were demonstratably cruel, ignorant and rude, the Elders continued to talk and argue their points, as they changed their minds about what to do.

The first thing that threw me was when one of the characters, Lawrence, rolled up his loose cotton pants before wading into the sea to collect mussels. The reference was only in passing, but I rolled my eyes, thinking that the author had made a silly mistake. When the Elders wore their best suits to attend the meeting and followed formal, long-established protocols I realised that the European clothing along with the Elders’ English names Walter, Gary, Gordon, Albert, Joseph and Nathanial had been deliberately chosen to demonstrate that the First Nations people had culture, history, laws, ceremonies and traditions, one of which was welcoming visitors to their country.

The author’s descriptions of the Gadigal area (Sydney), which included the sea, beaches and land were truly beautiful and the character’s knowledge of the birds, fish and animals as both food sources, weather and season forecasters and as cultural totems was interesting. The characters seemed very real and I liked that although the Elders who gathered on this day were all men, that was only because the women were already engaged in their own important business that same day.

The before and after of the Aboriginal people following the First Fleet’s arrival was particularly jarring.

This story was originally written as a play, which showed in the character’s dialogue. I would love to see the stage play of The Visitors in future.

My purchase of The Visitors continues my New Year’s resolution for 2024 to buy a book by an Australian author during each month of this year (February). I purchased The Visitors at The Bookshop in Queenscliff.

Comments on: "The Visitors by Jane Harrison" (7)

  1. This sounds like it is written from an interesting (and quite telling) perspective. I think I would most enjoy the parts about the birds, animals, and fish. I’m always fascinated by what some call “old wive’s tales”. So often those predictors (or whatever) end up being fairly accurate. I like social history. 

    • The perspective was indeed telling. As the descendant of settlers I definitely benefitted from the visitors taking what wasn’t theirs.
      Agreed, old wives tales are interesting and should be heeded, or at least considered.

  2. You’re reading so many interesting books about the first settlers Rose, would you recommend any one in particular or have they all been equally useful?

    • My absolute favourite has been Patrick White’s The Tree of Man, but a few readers (Sandra) tried this book and hated it!
      Loads of well-written books from the past about early settlers leave out any mention of the Aboriginal people, which offends present-day readers. Preservation by Jock Serong or The Secret River books by Kate Grenville are popular modern stories. I loved On A Bright Hillside in Paradise by Annette Higgs, too.

  3. The idea of giving them all English names and clothing sounds very odd – I’m not sure it would have worked for me. Is Harrison from a First Nations heritage?

    • The English names and clothing was very jarring at first, but then I relaxed into it.
      The author does have First Nations heritage, I probably should have noted that in my review. Her bio said is a descendant of the Murawari people from outback NSW.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud