Book reviews

I spun Silas Marner by George Eliot in The Classics Club’s spin #36 and have to admit to having been very pleased because I knew the book was short!

However, I still found the first half of Silas Marner to be a hard slog and couldn’t seem to get interested in the plot or the characters. Eventually something clicked and I loved the last half of the book. I’m now planning to re-read the first half.

The story is set ‘in the days when the spinning-wheels hummed busily in the farm houses’ near the village of Raveloe, where the title character, a weaver named Silas Marner lived in a quiet spot next to a deserted stone-pit. Silas had moved to the area after being falsely accused of stealing church funds when his best friend set up him up, then stole his girl.

The only real joy in Silas’s life was counting his gold he earned from his work, which he hid under beneath the floor of his home.

When the local Squire’s good-for-nothing son Dunsey stole Silas’s gold, Silas felt as if he had nothing left to live for. Dunsey went missing the same night as the theft, but no one connected the two events and so the identity of the thief was a mystery to Silas and the Raveloe community.

Godfrey, Dunsey’s older brother also had a secret, in his case, he had a wife who was addicted to opium. Dunsey had been threatening to expose Godfrey’s secret family to their father, Squire Cass, who would probably have kicked Godfrey out of his home and his will if he knew of Godfrey’s marriage, so Dunsey’s disappearance was a blessing for Godfrey.

Godfrey had outgrown his short-lived lust for his wife and was now in love with Nancy, the daughter of a neighbour. Both Godfrey and Nancy’s fathers hoped their children would marry and couldn’t understand why Godfrey wouldn’t get on with things.

When Godfrey’s wife decided to bring things to a head by taking their child with her to Squire Cass’s New Year’s Eve party, I became more interested in the story. The wife took opium then fell asleep in the snow during her journey and died, and Silas Marner, of all people, adopted the child, a little girl whose golden hair reminded him of his lost bags of gold. Silas’s love of little Eppie and hers for him brought about his redemption into society.

Godfrey recognised his child but she didn’t recognise him, so he kept quiet about who she was. Godfrey’s story eventually came to a head, also.

I liked that there were some happy endings and that characters who behaved badly were punished, although some characters experienced hardships they didn’t deserve as a result of their connections with those who did. I liked the messages and the characters, and little Eppie, whose character reminded me of Little Nell from The Old Curiosity Shop by Charles Dickens.

Silas Marner was book seven of my second Classics Club challenge to read 50 classics before my challenge end date of September 08, 2028.

Comments on: "Silas Marner by George Eliot" (12)

  1. Well, with 3 solid Eliot books under your belt, do you think you’ll search out any more by her?

    • I will read Adam Bede at some point as have had several people say how much they’ve liked this book. I’ve appreciated George Eliot rather than enjoyed her works, so probably won’t look too hard for others.

  2. I’m so glad you enjoyed this one! I vastly preferred it to Middlemarch, although I agree it takes a bit of time to get going. But I thought she handled the contrasting dark and light in the story well, and little Eppie isn’t as nauseating as fictional children from that era often are!

  3. I’m glad you ended up liking this. I have considered adding it to my next CC list. The only book of hers I’ve read is Middlemarch which took some effort! I have a while to decide.

  4. I’m glad you’re going back to read the first half again, I love Silas Marner! Have you seen the film with Ben Kingsley and Patsy Kensit? I haven’t seen it for years but I remember enjoying it. The relationship between SM and Eppie is one I think of quite often, probably everytime I see toffees wrapped in golden paper!

    • I haven’t seen the film but am looking forward to it. Your comment about toffees makes me think I should make or buy some to eat while I watch. Probably safer if I don’t make them, last time I did, He Who Eats All of Our leftovers lost a filling!

  5. That’s so funny (not for him though). Is it a collection of Quality Street tins you have? It’s those golden pennies. . .

  6. I felt the same about Middlemarch. The beginning was so-o-o slow but I built up a head of steam and finished nicely. Thanks for sharing. I have a copy of Silas Marner waiting for me on my book shelf.

    Here is my Spin classic: OLD MAN AND THE SEA

  7. I had Middlemarch on my list for quite a while, but have always been daunted by the length and not knowing if I’ll like Eliot’s writing. This sounds like it might be a better book to introduce myself to her with, if only because it’s not long! Great review.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tag Cloud